Critical Analysis on a Tina Modotti Photograph Essay -- Papers

Critical Analysis on a Tina Modotti Photograph Tina Modotti was from a very poor working class society. She was brought up in the northeast part of Italy, in Udine, Friuli. She was born at the tail end of the industrial revolution, in 1896. However, you could say, by all means, that her village hadn't changed the slightest since the seventh century. She lived vigorously throughout her childhood, working endless hours in a silk-textile factory to earn a cash flow and to support the family through starvation. After their father had abandoned them when Tina was twelve and fled to America, the land of dreams, to repeat, Tina was the family's sole breadwinner, and played an essential role in the escape from starvation and the gradual escape to San Francisco. Finally, in America she immediately found work, however it was a similar kind of sweatshop labour she was used to in Italy, but the modern land and the general experience itself filled her with self believe and self esteem. The photograph represents a metaphoric symbol of a pair of working class puppeteer hands and one of them is controlling the other. It is symbolizing the way the government controls the working class, as if the working class were puppets themselves. It is an extremely clever metaphor. They are compared to the government and the government seems to be deciding the fate or even controlling the working class's life. The immense, rough hand above represents the government and therefore, controlling the feeble, knotted one below. In my opinion, the photograph by Tina Modotti symbolises power above all else. There is also a great contrast in the lighting. Firstly, b... ...e) rapped in thick wire. It is being controlled by all the other feet, who are the puppeteers. They are the rich class so therefore, they marginalise the poor because of there lack of money and even freedom. The central foot's fate is in the hands of all the other personalities (feet). Like Tina Modotti's photograph, my piece of art would represent a metaphor, showing how the rich dictate and marginalise the poor. Similarly, how we spend money ad fuss over unnecessary items, for instance a pair on expensive Nike trainers or a pair of golden ear rings. On the other hand, the poor, inn most cases, can't even afford education, or even health services, which is vital for our survival in life. In conclusion, this is what I would like my message to be, I would hopefully try a produce one similar through my piece of art work.